A Crimean bridge Ukraine had to break

OpinionA Crimean bridge Ukraine had to break

The destruction of a key road portion of Russia’s Kerch Bridge is a major strategic victory for Ukraine. While the bridge’s railway link remains operational, the heavy destruction caused by two days of Ukrainian attacks will add to Russian difficulties in Crimea and its war effort at large.

Ukraine had to carry out this attack.

The Kerch Bridge is a key prestige project for President Vladimir Putin. Linking the Russian mainland to the Ukrainian peninsula that Russia has occupied since 2014, the bridge brought physical form to Putin’s claims of spiritual and sovereign authority over Crimea. Amid escalating and deliberate Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilians, this attack offers a major morale boost for Ukraine. For these same reasons, the Kremlin has always been very sensitive about this bridge.

I can personally attest to that sensitivity.

Shortly after the bridge first opened in 2018, I argued that Ukraine conduct a night attack (to avoid civilian casualties) to destroy it. In hindsight, it was a poor argument to make at that time. After all, it would have given Russia a casus belli to invade Ukraine at scale in a situation where Ukraine was not ready to resist such an invasion. That’s plainly not the case today. And the fundamental principle of my earlier argument is the same that motivated Ukraine to carry out this attack. Namely, that “any state that allows its territory to be stolen and then bound up with the thief has taken a step towards extinction.”

This didn’t go down very well in Moscow. Following years of targeted harassment, Russia issued a warrant for my arrest in 2024. I remain grateful for the backing of the Washington Examiner and our editorial director Hugo Gurdon (whose support also made him a target of Russian ire). But I also remain resolute in the belief that this bridge had to go. That interest is made even more imperative amid the current war.

Since Russia began its full-scale war on Ukraine in February 2022, the bridge has been a key logistics node for its forces and administrative authorities in Crimea. This node has become increasingly important as Ukrainian strikes have destroyed Russian fuel depots and military targets on the peninsula. Crimea is also suffering a longstanding water shortage. Alongside Ukrainian drone attacks on supply vessels in the Black Sea, Russia’s hold over Crimea has become increasingly precarious and expensive to maintain. Making matters worse, wreckage from the bridge is now obstructing the only available sea passage route for large ships into the Sea of Azov. This will further hamper exports from Russian and Russian occupied ports. Resupply of Crimea is now effectively dependent on land crossings through occupied southern Ukraine that are highly vulnerable to Ukrainian attack.

Yet, Ukraine’s preeminent strategic gains here are political in nature.

First, Ukraine has proven to the world and, of particular importance, the Trump administration, that it is very far from defeated. On the contrary, this attack makes Putin look vulnerable at exactly the moment when he wants to appear strong. After all, the bridge attack coincided with Putin’s attendance at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China. Putin wanted to use that summit to broadcast strength to his key benefactor, Chinese President Xi Jinping. He also wanted to be able to present strength to President Donald Trump in advance of a trilateral meeting with Xi on Thursday. Instead, nearly six years and 450,000 Russian dead soldiers into a war that was supposed to last a matter of weeks, Putin’s key prestige project has been hammered.

Which is also why the Kerch Bridge matters so much. It reinforces the reality of Putin’s failure. Even with Russia’s economy dedicated to the war, Putin has been unable to make major territorial gains. Yes, Putin could adopt a total war footing with a full mobilization drive. But even then, it’s far from clear that Russia could secure victory. Taking that option would also risk turning the Russian people against him. Putin knows as much, hence why he has aggressively restricted public anti-war dissent.

IN UK ARREST OF US SOLDIER, A REMINDER RUSSIA CAN SPY EFFECTIVELY

Putin’s great fear is losing the popular perception that he has restored Russian national pride. As was the case for Tsar Nicholas I amid Russia’s 1856 defeat in the Crimean War. As Orlando Figes notes in his book The Crimean War, that defeat meant “Everything was open to question. The Crimean disaster had exposed the shortcomings of every institution in Russia … critics focused on Nicholas I, whose arrogant and willful policies had led the country to ruin and sacrificed so many lives.” Figes notes a Tsarist censor, Alexander Nikitenko’s attitude. The war, Nikitenko concluded, was “All at the behest of a mad will, drunk with absolute power and arrogance. … What was the point of it all? What profit, what glory has Russia reaped from this?”

A shattered monument to imperial arrogance, the Kerch Bridge risks Russia repeating that historic lamentation.

Check out our other content

Check out other tags:

Most Popular Articles